• WTI closes at $42.44, its highest since September 1.
  • Oil has gained 13.9% in November but remains below the March break.
  • US equities have set new records predicting recovery.
  • Atlanta Fed GDPNow estimates 5.6% annualized growth in Q4.
  • Dollar will respond to US economic growth which fracking and inexpensive oil facilitates.

The recovery in crude oil, is like almost everything else in the global economy, a one variant function. Tame the COVID-19 pandemic and all else follows.

West Texas Intermediate (WTI) prices rose 1% on Friday, capping a 5.1% week and a 13.9% month. This is the fourth time since the great pandemic collapse in the spring that crude has approached the underside of its three year range before COVID-19. Each time it has failed to break through.

The $44-$46 price band has acted like a chasm that traders have been unable to vault.

West Texas Intermediate

It is not whether a recovering global economy can drive prices back above $50. It will.

One question is timing. When will traders have sufficient confidence that the recovery is nearing to speculate on prices? Or to put it more directly, when can we be sure that the pandemic will not derail the economy yet again.

A second question is how far can prices rise with idle fracking fields in North American waiting for activation? The answer is the pricing and cost structure has been permanently altered by vast new supplies of crude oil. Barrel prices above $75 are likely a thing of the past.

West Texas Intermediate

US economy: If not a V then what?

The recovery from the -31.4% crash in GDP in the second quarter with a 33.1% burst in annualized growth in July, August and September, is textbook for the much-derided V-shaped recovery, at least for economic activity.

US GDP, annualized


Labor market metrics have not prospered to the same degree. The unemployment rate has more than halved from 14.7% in April to 6.9% in October but it is still almost double its 3.5% reading in February. Nonfarm Payrolls have replaced or rehired just 54% of the 22.16 million workers displaced by the pandemic lockdowns in March and April. Many of those service sector jobs have disappeared.

For the moment the GDP recovery is predicted to continue into the fourth quarter. The Atlanta Fed GDPNow model estimates the economy is expanding at a 5.6% annual rate in the final quarter. That is an excellent rate at any time, in current circumstances it is both surprising and very welcome.

Equities vs WTI

The contrast between US equity averages which have topped their per-pandemic records and West Texas Intermediate is striking.

In eight months the Dow has gained an astonishing 61% from its March 23 panic low at 18591 to close at a new record of 29950 on November 16. The prior high on February 12th was 29,551. The new record is just 1.4% above the old, but considering the conditions since March, it is one of the more remarkable moves in financial history.

The S&P 500 has jumped 62% from its March low to last week’s high at 3,626. It is 7% over it per-pandemic high of 3386 from February 19 and has seen a good portion of trading since August 8 above the old record.


Price action in both markets discounts the future. If you think the economy is headed for a boom once the pandemic loosens its grip, the demand for crude oil will rise as surely as equity profits.

The Fed and fracking

There are two main differences in pricing, one for stocks and the other specific to oil, that have supported equities and inhibited crude.

The Federal Reserve has made low interest rates the cornerstone of pandemic banking policy. The governors cut the fed funds rate to 0.25% in early March and they have kept the effective rate even lower with a bond buying program.

The impact of this is evident in the yield on the 10-year Treasury. On the last day of 2019 the 10-year Treasury yield was 1.919% and on February 5 it was 1.649%. A little over one month later on March 9 the same yield was 0.498%, an all-time low. On Friday the close for this bond was 0.824% less than half the yield before the Fed policy.


In providing liquidity to the US economy the Fed has also supplied it to the equity markets. Some of that funding and the ability to borrow at near record low cost has certainly made its way to stocks in search of return boosting prices.

The advent of fracking in the United States and Canada has changed oil production and supply dramatically. From being a major importer of crude, the US has become a net-exporter. The US is now the world’s largest producer of energy, primarily oil and natural gas. The US and Canada also have vast untapped supplies of oil and natural gas.

These factors and the facility of US producers in reducing production costs have permanently brought down the price of oil.

Conclusion and the dollar

Equities and WTI operate with the same set of economic expectations. Prices, however, are the product of two very different markets.

Interest rates and liquidity provisions from the central bank have given the financial sector a temporary boost.

Fracking has permanently increased the supply of crude oil the industry is able to produce. North American shale drillers have become the swing producers in the global market. They are unrestricted by government quotas in the US or Canada. Their restriction is profitability. As the market adage goes-high prices are their own cure.

With the Federal Reserve projected in its own estimates to be on hold until the end of 2023 the dollar next year will depend on US economic growth for support. Low energy prices are a boon to any economy. For the worlds largest user of energy, the proportional advantage is substantial.